How NFL Pick'em and Confidence Pools Work

A pick'em pool is one of the simplest football pools to run with a group. Everyone picks a team in every NFL game, every week. Right picks score points, and the pool keeps a winner for each week and standings for the whole season. Nobody is knocked out, so a bad Sunday costs you points, not your place in the pool.

How a Pick'em Pool Works

One person starts the pool as its commissioner and sends the group its link. Each week, every entry picks a team in every game on the NFL schedule, and every right pick scores points. A pool runs from the week it starts through Week 18, the last week of the regular season, or through the Super Bowl when the commissioner chooses the playoffs.

The commissioner sets the rules when starting the pool: straight up or against the spread, confidence points on or off, when picks lock, what happens to a missed pick, and how many entries each person may have, from 1 to 10. The rules can change until the pool's first pick locks. After that they stay as they are.

Unless the commissioner closes joining, new entries can join all season, up to the number of entries the pool's plan covers. An entry that joins late picks every game that has not locked yet, and a game that locked before it joined scores zero for it.

Straight Up or Against the Spread

In a straight-up pool you pick the team you think will win. A tie scores no points for anyone.

In a pool against the spread, you pick the team you think will cover the point spread. Each week's lines become final on Wednesday at 12:00 PM ET, before the week's first game. A game with no line at that moment gets its final line if one appears before the week's first kickoff. Every pick is graded on its game's final line, so a line that moves later changes nothing.

When a whole-number line becomes final, it moves half a point toward zero, so -3 becomes -2.5. A team favored by 3 that wins by exactly 3 covers. The only line that can end in a push is 0, where neither team is favored, and a push scores no points.

A game with no final line by the week's first kickoff does not count in a pool against the spread: nobody scores on it. Until the lines are final, the pick sheet shows each game's current line and marks it as not final.

Confidence Points

With confidence points on, you also rank your picks each week. Every pick holds a value from 1 up to the number of games that week, and each value is used once. In a 16-game week your surest pick is worth 16 points and your shakiest is worth 1. A right pick scores its value, and a wrong one scores nothing. With confidence points off, every right pick is worth 1 point.

Each pick takes the highest value still free when you tap it, so in a 16-game week, picks you never rank are worth 16, 15, 14 and so on, in the order you tapped them. Ranking puts your picks in the order you choose, surest first, and gives them the highest values still free. A pick you add after ranking takes the highest value left, below the ones you ranked, so rank again if it belongs higher.

Changing a pick to the other team keeps its value. Clearing a pick frees its value for another game.

Once a game locks, its pick and its value stay where they are. In a pool where each game locks at its own kickoff, you can keep reordering the games still to play, but a value never moves onto or off a game that has started. If a game is called off, nobody scores on it, and a value on it stays there: it is not handed to another game.

When Picks Lock

The commissioner chooses one of two lock rules:

  • Each game at its kickoff. A pick can change until its own game kicks off, so a Sunday pick can wait until Sunday.
  • The whole week at its first kickoff. Every pick for the week locks when the week's first game kicks off.

Until a pick locks, only you can see it. Once a game locks, everyone in the pool can see every entry's pick on it, with its value when confidence points are on, and how many entries took each side. Locks are final: if a game is moved after its picks lock, they stay locked.

Missed Picks

The commissioner also chooses what happens when a game locks and an entry has no pick on it:

  • Scores zero. The game scores nothing for that entry.
  • Gets the favorite. The entry is given the team favored by the week's final line, marked as an automatic pick. At a line of 0, that is the home team.

With confidence points on, an automatic pick uses up the lowest value the entry has left, and it is worth 1 point, whatever that value is.

Under either rule, a missed pick scores zero on a game that locked before the entry joined, and on a game with no final line by the week's first kickoff, since there is no favorite to give.

The Weekly Tiebreaker

Each week, every entry also guesses the final score of the week's last game: each team's points, as a whole number from 0 to 99. The pick sheet names the game. The guess locks when that game kicks off, or at the week's first kickoff in a pool where the whole week locks then.

The week goes to the entry with the most points. If entries are tied, the guess whose total is closest to the real total wins, over or under. If it's still tied, the closest home score wins, then the closest away score, then the entry with more season points through that week. An entry with no guess loses the tie to any entry that has one. Entries still tied after all of that share the week. If the tiebreaker game is called off, the entry with more season points through that week wins, and entries still tied share the week.

Weekly and Season Standings

Every game is graded as it goes final, and the standings follow. A week has its winner once all of its games are done. The season standings add up every week's points from the pool's first week and count each entry's weekly wins, a shared week included. Entries tied on season points share the place, or, in a pool whose season tiebreaker is Most weekly wins, the entry with more weekly wins takes it. The weekly tiebreaker game never decides the season.

If a final score is corrected, the game's picks are graded again, and points can move either way.

Strategy

Put Your Top Values on Your Surest Picks

In a confidence pool, the order of your picks matters as much as the picks. A wrong pick worth 16 costs you 16 points, and a wrong pick worth 1 costs you 1. Put your highest values on the games you are surest of and your lowest on the ones that feel like a coin flip.

Rank your picks every week. Left in the order you tapped them, your first pick carries your highest value, whether or not it is your surest.

Picking With Your Pool or Against It

A week is won against the other entries in your pool, not against the schedule. When every entry takes the same team in a game, the pick itself separates nobody. Without confidence points, that game cannot change the order. With them, only the values on it can. Either way, the week comes down to where entries differ.

Going against your pool on a close game is how an entry makes up ground in a week, and also how it falls behind. If you are chasing the season leaders, you need picks that differ from theirs somewhere. If you are ahead, picking with the pool keeps the gap. Picks stay hidden until they lock, so this is a read on your group, not a lookup.

In a confidence pool, the value you put on it matters as much as the pick. Going against the pool with a pick worth 2 risks 2 points. The same pick worth 15 can swing the whole week.

Against the Spread

Against the spread, a strong team can win and still fail to cover. The team you are surest will win is not always the pick you are surest will cover, so rank your confidence on covering, not on winning.

News keeps coming after the lines are final. In a pool where each game locks at its own kickoff, a Sunday pick can wait for the latest injury news, and the pool's spread for that game will not change while you wait.

Don't Lean on Automatic Picks

Make your picks before they lock. If your pool gives a missed pick the favorite, that is a safety net, not a strategy: in a confidence pool an automatic pick is worth 1 point.

Using the Tiebreaker

Fill it in every week. Unless the tiebreaker game is called off, an entry with no guess loses a tied week to any entry that has one. Base it on the two teams in that game and how they play. The total counts first, then each team's score. Closest wins, over or under, so there is no trick to it: make your honest best guess.

More Than One Entry

If your pool allows more than one entry each, make them differ where it matters, on a few close games or in the order of your top values, rather than copies with one game swapped. Entries that agree rise and fall together.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a confidence pool?

A pick'em pool where you also rank your picks each week. Each pick holds a value from 1 up to the number of games that week, each value used once, and a right pick scores its value. In a 16-game week your surest pick is worth 16 points and your shakiest is worth 1.

What is the difference between straight up and against the spread?

Straight up, you pick the team you think will win. Against the spread, you pick the team you think will cover the point spread, graded on the game's final line: lines become final on Wednesday at 12:00 PM ET, or, for a game with no line by then, once one appears before the week's first kickoff. The commissioner chooses one for the whole pool.

When do picks lock?

It is the commissioner's choice: each game at its own kickoff, or the whole week at its first kickoff. Until a pick locks, only you can see it.

What happens if I miss a pick?

It depends on the pool's rule, which the commissioner chooses. A missed pick either scores zero or gets the favorite by the week's final line, marked as an automatic pick. In a confidence pool an automatic pick uses up the lowest value you have left and is worth 1 point.

What if a game ends in a tie?

Straight up, a tie scores no points for anyone. Against the spread, a tie is graded on the line like any other score, so the underdog covers. Only a line of 0 turns a tie into a push, and a push scores no points.

How does the tiebreaker work?

Each week every entry guesses the final score of the week's last game. If entries are tied on points for the week, the guess closest to the real total wins, over or under. If it's still tied, the closest home score wins, then the closest away score, then more season points through that week. An entry with no guess loses the tie to any entry that has one. Entries still tied share the week. If the tiebreaker game is called off, the entry with more season points through that week wins, and entries still tied share it. The tiebreaker game decides weeks only. A tie on season points follows the pool's season tiebreaker: entries share the place, or the one with more weekly wins takes it, and entries still tied share it.

Start a Pick'em Pool

Start a pool, choose its rules, and send your group the link. Pools of up to 10 entries are free.

Start a pick'em pool →

If your group would rather make one pick a week, where one wrong pick can end your season, read how a survivor pool works.