Multiple Survivor Entries: Same Team or Different Teams? What 10 Seasons Show

Most survivor advice is written for one entry in one pool. Plenty of people play two, three or more, and every week they face a question the usual advice skips: should my entries take the same team, or different ones?

Putting both on the week's biggest favorite feels safe. So we tested it, against ten real NFL seasons.

The short answer

Give each entry a different team. With two entries on different teams, a player still had at least one alive after Week 8 27% of the time. With both on the same team, 17%. Different teams came out ahead in every one of the ten seasons, and never once fell behind in any week.

How we tested it

We took every regular season game from 2016 to 2025: the final score, and the betting line that said how big a favorite each team was. Then we replayed each season 20,000 times with simulated players who pick the way most people do. Half the time they take the biggest favorite they have left, a quarter of the time the next one, and so on down their top five. They never reuse a team, and a tie counts as a loss, which is Sunday Survivor's default.

Every player had two entries. Half of them put both entries on the same team every week. The other half never let their entries share one. Nothing else was different.

What happened

The chance a player still had at least one of their two entries alive:

AfterSame teamDifferent teams
Week 171%92%
Week 265%82%
Week 441%60%
Week 624%38%
Week 817%27%
Week 108%14%
Week 124%7%

On average, a player's longest-lasting entry made it through 3.6 weeks with both on the same team, and 5.1 weeks with different teams.

Two entries on one team are really one entry

The same-team column is exactly what a single entry does, because that is what it is. The two entries win together and lose together. In our replay they went out in the same week 99% of the time, and the rest survived the whole season. Entries on different teams went out together 14% of the time.

That is the whole case for spreading out. Over these ten seasons, the week's biggest favorite lost 25 times, about once every seven weeks. The weeks the biggest favorite loses, a player with both entries on that team is finished, and a player with the second entry somewhere else is still playing.

What it costs

The second entry usually gets a slightly weaker team, and that has a price. Out of 100 two-entry players, the same-team players had 34 entries still alive after Week 8, and the different-team players had 29.

Look at where those entries are, though. The same-team entries belonged to 17 players, two each. The different-team entries were spread across 27 players. In a pool where the last entry standing wins, what matters is whether you are still in it.

More entries, bigger difference

The more entries you run on different teams, the longer you last. The chance of still having at least one alive after Week 8:

  • One entry, or any number on the same team: 17%
  • Two entries on different teams: 27%
  • Three entries on different teams: 35%
  • Five entries on different teams: 47%

A player's longest-lasting entry made it through 3.6 weeks with one entry, 5.1 with two, 6.1 with three and 7.3 with five.

Did it hold every year?

Yes. Players with entries on different teams were ahead after Week 8 in every one of the ten seasons, and they never once fell behind in any week. The only weeks they merely tied were three early ones, when the biggest favorites all won.

Then we checked that it was not just our way of picking:

  • Players who spread their picks across many more favorites, taking the biggest one only about 27% of the time: 10% against 18% after Week 8.
  • Players who take the biggest favorite they have left nine times in ten: 30% against 33% after Week 8, and 8% against 13% after Week 12.

Different teams came out ahead under every way of picking we tried, but by how much depends on how you pick. If you nearly always take the single biggest favorite, splitting buys you less, and your second entry pays more for it, because it is always on the second-best team.

What this does not tell you

  • It measures surviving, not winning. Whether you win depends on everyone else in your pool, and this replay does not model them.
  • It does not cover buybacks, mulligans or double pick weeks. Each of those changes how long entries last.
  • It is about the past. Ten seasons is a lot of football, but it is not a forecast for any week ahead.

Using it this week

Our weekly picks guide ranks the best options and says which teams are worth saving, and that advice is written for one entry. If you have two, take our top pick with one and the next option on the list with the other. With three or more, keep going down the list.

Common questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Should two of my entries ever take the same team?

In a pool where the last entry standing wins, our replay of ten seasons says no. Two entries on one team are really one entry: they went out in the same week 99% of the time.

The one case for it is a pool where every entry still alive at the end shares first place. Then two entries on a path that lasts finish as two co-champions. That is a bet on one path lasting the whole season, and in our replay one did less than 1% of the time.

Doesn't my second entry end up with a worse team?

Yes, a slightly weaker one most weeks, and it costs a little. Out of 100 two-entry players, the same-team players had 34 entries still alive after Week 8 and the different-team players had 29. But the same-team entries sat with 17 players, two apiece, while the different-team entries were spread across 27 players. In a last-one-standing pool, what counts is whether you still have an entry.

Does it still hold with three or more entries?

It gets stronger. A player with three entries on different teams still had one alive after Week 8 35% of the time, and with five, 47%, against 17% for a single entry or for any number of entries all on the same team.

Where does the data come from?

Every regular season game from 2016 to 2025, with its final score and betting line, from nflverse and Lee Sharpe's nfldata schedule file. We used the moneyline to say how big a favorite each team was. These are past seasons, not a forecast for any week ahead. We rerun the numbers after every season, so the ten seasons are always the latest ten.

Does this tell me which team to pick?

No. It answers one question: whether your entries should share a team in the same week. For the week's actual options, see our weekly picks guide, and give each extra entry a different team from the list.

Game results and betting lines from nflverse and Lee Sharpe's nfldata schedule file, used for these totals only. Also worth reading: this week's picks and how to plan your teams across the season.

Ready to run your own pool?

Sunday Survivor runs the picks, the eliminations and the deadline reminders for you, with as many entries per person as your pool allows.

It is free to start. Set up your pool the way it should be →